Brand: e.l.f.Can the seller be trusted?
Analyzed
Analyzed
Pros
Stays put all dayMost reviewers
Reviewers say it resists smudging and lasts through heat, humidity, exercise, and even showers.
Precise, smooth applicationMany reviewers
Reviewers describe a fine tip that makes it easy to draw thin or thick lines and apply the liner smoothly.
Rich black colorMany reviewers
Reviewers praise the deep, solid black pigment and say the liner gives strong color payoff.
Good value for moneySome reviewers
Reviewers say it performs well compared with more expensive eyeliner brands and is inexpensive.
Cons
Can smudge or wear offA few reviewers
Some reviewers say it smudges, rubs off, or fails to withstand water and sweat.
Application can skipA few reviewers
Some reviewers say the liner skips, applies poorly, or lacks enough color on the tip.
Tip dries outA few reviewers
Reviewers report that the tip can become dry or sticky, making it difficult to apply or finish a line.
Inconsistent product flowA few reviewers
Some reviewers say the pen releases too much product, while another found it watery and runny.
Ready to Buy?
Prices and stock change often. See today's price and delivery options on Amazon.
Continue to AmazonTrusted Alternatives
Products from the same store and category whose reviews earned a Trust Score of 8 or more.





Advanced Insights
PremiumSee who's really selling the product and whether their track record earns your trust, whether today's price is a good deal, exactly why the reviews can or can't be trusted, and how its ratings have held up over time.
Unlock Advanced Insights
- Seller Reputation: who really sells it (Amazon, the brand or a reseller), and whether their history of buyer feedback says you can trust them
- Price Analysis: whether today's price is a real deal, measured against the category's best sellers and its own price history
- Review Authenticity: the evidence behind the Trust Score, from the signs the reviews are genuine to the red flags worth a second look, backed by real quotes
- Ratings History: how the rating has held up over time, with charts that flag vanishing ratings and merged listings
- Product Chat: ask anything about the product and get answers straight from its reviews and FakeFind's analysis
Renews automatically until you cancel; cancel anytime in your account. By subscribing you agree to the Terms and Refund Policy.

